-
Posted: November 18, 2026
Written by: Thomas A. KissaneCourt Allows Non-Signatory Principal to Compel Arbitration and Decides Arbitrability Where Arbitration Clauses Do Not Delegate It
On September 27, 2026, Justice Joel M. Cohen of the New York County Commercial Division held that an advertiser that did not sign a supply agreement could compel the counterparty to arbitrate, because the advertiser’s agent signed the agreement, and that the Court, not the arbitrator, decides arbitrability when the arbitration clauses do not clearly and unmistakably delegate that question. The case is Smaato, Inc. v. Zemanta, Inc., Index No. 651540/2026. Read More
-
Posted: November 16, 2026
Written by: Thomas A. KissaneCourt Sustains Financial Advisor’s Claim Under Contract Calling for 40% of Fees Client Paid Its Advisors on an Identified Transaction, Without Deciding Whether Client Was Obliged to Engage the Advisor on That Transaction
On October 8, 2026, Justice Andrea Masley of the New York County Commercial Division held that a financial advisor’s claim for a contractual payment equal to 40% of the total fees the client paid its financial advisors on an identified transaction that had not yet occurred when the parties signed the engagement letter was not barred as an unenforceable agreement to agree. The case is Perella Weinberg Partners LP v. Aspen Technology, Inc., Index No. 655294/2025. Read More
-
Posted: November 13, 2026
Written by: Ian WeissCourt Refuses To Compel Party To Produce Outside Consultant For Deposition As A Party Witness
On October 27, 2026, in Castle Apparel Ltd. v. Del Vecchio, Index No. 655335/2021, Justice Robert R. Reed of the New York County Commercial Division denied defendants’ request, raised in a Commercial Division Rule 14 discovery submission, for an order compelling plaintiffs to produce a consultant for deposition as a party witness. Defendants contended that the consultant had served as a document custodian for plaintiffs and had advised and negotiated for plaintiffs on matters defendants considered critical. Plaintiffs responded that the consultant was employed by a nonparty entity, had never been their employee, and was not someone they had the ability to compel to appear. Siding with Plaintiffs, the Court explained: Read More
-
Posted: November 11, 2026
Written by: Ian WeissCourt Holds Testimony Barred By Dead Man’s Statute Cannot Defeat Summary Judgment When The Only Other Evidence Is Hearsay
On October 28, 2026, in Slabakis v. Olympos Trading Corp., Index No. 653632/2021, Justice Robert R. Reed of the New York County Commercial Division granted defendants’ motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint. Plaintiff alleged that, in 1984, his now-deceased business partner agreed to buy plaintiff’s 20% interest in corporations that owned real estate in the New York City area, and sought to enforce that alleged agreement against the partner’s estate and successors. No copy of the alleged agreement, and no document showing plaintiff’s ownership interest, was produced, and plaintiff was the only living witness with purported firsthand knowledge of the agreement. New York’s Dead Man’s Statute, CPLR 4519, bars a person with an interest in the outcome of a case from testifying about a personal transaction with a deceased person against the decedent’s executor, administrator, or survivor. Plaintiff therefore could not testify at trial about his dealings with his late partner. The question was whether that testimony, together with evidence from several third-party witnesses, including a former bank loan officer and plaintiff’s accountant, could defeat summary judgment. The Court held it could not, explaining: Read More
-
Posted: November 9, 2026
Written by: Ian WeissCourt Holds Stablecoin Issuer Owed No Duty To Freeze Stolen Tokens Absent The Court Order Its Policy Required
On November 2, 2026, in Kaplan v. Circle Internet Group Inc., Index No. 650459/2026, Justice Joel M. Cohen of the New York County Commercial Division granted the motion of Circle Internet Group, Inc. and Circle Internet Financial, LLC (together, “Circle”) to dismiss the amended complaint against them. Plaintiff alleged that an unidentified thief stole more than $13 million of USDC, a stablecoin that Circle issues and administers, from plaintiff’s cryptocurrency wallet. Plaintiff alleged that Circle had the ability to freeze the stolen USDC remaining in the thief’s wallet but declined his requests to do so because its then-applicable policy required a court order, and that, before the court issued a temporary restraining order, the thief had swapped all of the stolen USDC for other cryptocurrency. Plaintiff had no prior relationship with Circle. The court dismissed plaintiff’s negligence and aiding-and-abetting claims against Circle, holding that Circle owed plaintiff no duty to act. The Court explained: Read More
-
Posted: November 6, 2026
Written by: Samuel L. ButtCourt Denies Motion To Stay Action On Promissory Note Because Related California Action Involved Different Parties And Notes
On October 13, 2026, in Promise Homes Co. LLC v. Promise Homes Investment, LLC, Index No. 654322/2025, Justice Robert R. Reed denied defendant’s motion to stay the action under C.P.L.R. 2201. In denying the stay, the Court explained: Read More
-
Posted: November 4, 2026
Written by: Samuel L. ButtCourt Holds Fund Manager’s Disclosed Fee Interest Did Not Strip Its Decisions Of Business Judgment Protection
On October 9, 2026, in Chen Dongwu v. New York City Regional Center LLC, Index No. 652024/2017, Justice Robert R. Reed granted defendants’ motion for summary judgment dismissing all of plaintiffs’ remaining claims. Read More
-
Posted: November 2, 2026
Written by: Samuel L. ButtCourt Refuses To Dismiss In-House Lawyer’s Statutory Whistleblower Claim Based On Attorney Confidentiality Obligations
On October 1, 2026, in Abramov v. Capula Investment US LP, Index No. 651251/2026, Justice Joel M. Cohen denied defendants’ motion to dismiss a whistleblower retaliation claim under Labor Law § 740. Read More
-
Posted: October 30, 2026
Written by: Channing J. TurnerCourt Declines To Limit Or Bifurcate Early Document Discovery Of Financial, Accounting, Tax, And Payment Records
On October 5, 2026, in Casita, L.P. v. Maplewood Equity Partners (Offshore) Ltd., Index No. 653122/2025, Justice Robert R. Reed of the New York County Commercial Division directed defendants to respond to a plaintiff’s document demands and declined to limit or bifurcate discovery at an early stage of the case. Plaintiff, an equity fund investor, sued the fund’s managing members for breach of contract, seeking to enforce the accounting and fund distribution terms of a subscription agreement. Plaintiff sought documents concerning fund distributions, accounting and tax records, non-privileged fee and retainer documents, and account transfers. Defendants opposed production of certain documents on the ground that, at this early stage, discovery should be limited. The Court found that none of those categories fell within the CPLR’s protected categories. It explained: Read More
-
Posted: October 28, 2026
Written by: Channing J. TurnerCourt Permits Pro Se Individual To Sue As Assignee Of LLC’s Claims, Overruling Objection That LLC’s Must Appear In Court Through Legal Counsel
On October 6, 2026, in Webb v. Infusion Capital Group LLC, Index No. 659826/2025, Justice Robert R. Reed of the New York County Commercial Division denied defendants’ motion to dismiss an amended complaint brought by an individual appearing pro se, both on his own behalf and as assignee of a limited liability company’s claims. The action arises from an alleged agreement to purchase future receivables from RP Palm Beach LLC, which does business as Roxy’s Pub. Plaintiff John Webb sought declarations that defendants lacked authority to enforce the agreement or, alternatively, that the agreement was a criminally usurious loan. Defendants moved under C.P.L.R. 3211(a)(3) and 321(a), arguing that the LLC lacked capacity because it had not obtained a certificate of authority to do business in New York, and that a corporate entity may not appear without counsel. The Court found that defendants offered no evidence that the LLC was doing business in New York, and it also denied plaintiff’s cross-motion for sanctions. On the pro se issue, the Court explained: Read More
-
Posted: October 26, 2026
Written by: Channing J. TurnerCommercial Division Adopts New Rule 14-b Requiring Specifics In Requests For Discovery Cost Shifting
On October 19, 2026, the Chief Administrative Judge of the Courts signed an administrative order (AO/306/2026) adding new Rule 14-b to the Commercial Division Rules (22 N.Y.C.R.R. § 202.70), effective December 1, 2026. The new rule provides: Read More
-
Posted: October 23, 2026
Written by: Thomas A. KissaneCourt Requires Notice and Proof of Receipt Before Compelling Nonparty Compliance with Post Judgment Subpoenas
On September 29, 2026, Justice Robert R. Reed of the New York County Commercial Division held that a judgment creditor seeking to compel a nonparty’s compliance with a post-judgment subpoena must give the nonparty notice of the requested relief and establish the nonparty’s actual receipt of the subpoena. The case is ACM MCC VI LLC v. Able Liquidation Three, Index No. 657261/2019. Read More
-
Posted: October 21, 2026
Written by: Thomas A. KissaneFirst Department Holds Performance of Existing Contractual Duties Does Not Establish Reliance for Fraud
On October 8, 2026, the Appellate Division, First Department held that a plaintiff does not plead detrimental reliance for fraud where the conduct allegedly induced by the misrepresentations consists of pre-existing contractual obligations. The case is Iberdrola Energy Projects v. Oaktree Capital Mgt., L.P., Case No. 2025-03514, affirming judgment by Justice Jennifer G. Schecter of the New York County Commercial Division, Index No. 652514/2021. Read More
-
Posted: October 19, 2026
Written by: Thomas A. KissaneCourt Holds Proven Fraudulent Conveyance Does Not Support Damages Duplicating Contract Recovery
On September 29, 2026, Justice Robert R. Reed of the New York County Commercial Division held that proof of a fraudulent conveyance does not support a separate damages recovery where the creditor’s loss is already addressed by its breach-of-contract claim. The case is Borden LP v. Sixth St. Partners, LLC, Index No. 657398/2017. Read More
-
Posted: October 16, 2026
Written by: Ian WeissIn Veil-Piercing Claim, First Department Holds “Transaction Attacked” Does Not Need To Be Transaction From Which Judgment Debtor’s Liability Arose
On September 24, 2026, in UBS Securities LLC v. Dondero, Index No. 650744/23, Case No. 2025-02596, the Appellate Division, First Department, largely affirmed an order of Justice Melissa A. Crane of the New York County Commercial Division denying motions to dismiss a turnover petition asserting a veil-piercing claim. UBS, a judgment creditor, alleged that James Dondero dominated the judgment debtors and used that domination to strip them of their assets and render them judgment proof. A veil-piercing plaintiff must show that the owner dominated the entity “in respect to the transaction attacked.” Dondero argued that the transaction attacked was the underlying transaction that gave rise to UBS’s judgments (the Knox Transaction), and that UBS had not alleged that he dominated the judgment debtors with respect to that transaction. The Court disagreed, explaining: Read More
-
Posted: October 14, 2026
Written by: Ian WeissCourt Holds Premature Notice Exercising Option Invalid Under New York’s Strict Construction Rule
On September 8, 2026, in ET JV Holdings, LLC v. TBH-ASL BSA Member LLC, Index No. 659784/2024, Justice Anar Rathod Patel of the New York County Commercial Division granted in part and denied in part the parties’ cross-motions for summary judgment. The operating agreement of a joint venture gave designer Elie Tahari a one-time right to buy out his co-member’s interest for $50 million “by providing written notice” during a 120-day period beginning December 29, 2024. Plaintiffs, Tahari and his affiliates, served the notice on December 2, 2024, about four weeks early. Defendants rejected it and began pursuing a sale to a third-party buyer at a $140 million valuation, which a valid buy-back would have defeated. Plaintiffs argued that the early notice should nevertheless be deemed effective, requiring defendants to sell their interest to Tahari, because no New York authority holds an early notice defective, and because defendants had actual notice and suffered no prejudice. The Court determined that the notice had to be served within the 120-day period and held the December 2 notice invalid. As a result, defendants were not required to sell their interest to Tahari on the strength of that notice. In reaching that holding, the Court explained: Read More
-
Posted: October 12, 2026
Written by: Ian WeissFirst Department Holds Each Player’s Concussion Claim Is At Least One Separate “Occurrence” Under NFL’s Liability Policies
On October 1, 2026, in Discover Property & Casualty Co. v. National Football League, Index No. 652933/12, Case Nos. 2025-03691 and 2025-03200, the Appellate Division, First Department, held that each former player’s claim resolved in the NFL’s concussion settlement constituted at least one separate “occurrence” under the NFL’s liability insurance policies, whose limits applied per occurrence. The NFL’s insurer, TIG, argued that all of the players’ injuries arose from a single occurrence—NFL play—so that only one set of limits applied. New York courts determine the number of occurrences under the “unfortunate event” test, which asks “whether there is a close temporal and spatial relationship between the incidents giving rise to injury or loss, and whether the incidents can be viewed as part of the same causal continuum, without intervening agents or factors.” Applying that test, the Court explained: Read More
-
Posted: October 9, 2026
Written by: Samuel L. ButtFirst Department Holds Certificate Holder Whose Certificates Had Zero Principal Balance Could Not Satisfy No-Action Clause’s Voting Rights Threshold
On August 27, 2026, in Matter of HBK Master Fund L.P. v. NewRez LLC, 252 AD3d 438, Index No. 656286/23, the Appellate Division, First Department unanimously affirmed an order of Justice Andrea Masley of the New York County Commercial Division dismissing a certificate holder’s claims against the servicer of a residential mortgage-backed securities trust. Read More
-
Posted: October 7, 2026
Written by: Samuel L. ButtDivided First Department Holds That “Commits To Raise” Language Does Not Require A Binding Agreement
On September 22, 2026, in Aurelius Capital Master Ltd. v. Hertz International Limited, Index No. 654710/21, Case No. 2025-00690, the Appellate Division, First Department affirmed a judgment of Justice Jennifer G. Schecter of the New York County Commercial Division that, after a nonjury trial, awarded plaintiffs approximately $15.9 million. Read More
-
Posted: October 5, 2026
Written by: Samuel L. ButtCourt Permits Limited Post-Note Of Issue Discovery Despite Untimely Motion To Vacate Note Of Issue
On September 2, 2026, in Python Financial Solutions, Inc. v. SDCK I LLC, Index No. 653659/2025, Justice Robert R. Reed granted in part defendant’s unopposed motion to vacate the note of issue, permitting limited post-note of issue discovery without vacating the note of issue. Read More