Commercial Division Blog
Court Dismisses Claims Against Law Firm Based on Peruvian Affiliate’s Engagement, Declining to Treat Verein Members as a Single Firm
Posted: November 20, 2026 / Written by: Thomas A. Kissane / Categories Agency, Fiduciary Duties, Jurisdiction, Motion to Dismiss
Court Dismisses Claims Against Law Firm Based on Peruvian Affiliate’s Engagement, Declining to Treat Verein Members as a Single Firm
On October 3, 2026, Justice Andrea Masley of the New York County Commercial Division held that plaintiffs could not hold Baker & McKenzie LLP liable for breach of an engagement letter signed by its Peruvian affiliate, or for breach of fiduciary duty, based on both firms’ membership in the Baker & McKenzie International verein, and that the Court lacked personal jurisdiction over the Peruvian firm. The case is Silverpeak Strategic Partners LP v. Baker & McKenzie LLP, Index No. 650905/2025.
Plaintiffs Silverpeak Strategic Partners LP and Phoeninca Investments LLC alleged that Baker & McKenzie LLP (“Baker LLP”) breached the engagement letter between Silverpeak and Estudio Luis Echecopar Garcia S.R.L. (“ELEG”), a Peruvian firm retained in 2016 on a fuel-distribution opportunity in Peru, and breached a fiduciary duty, by representing Lukoil in later litigation adverse to plaintiffs. Baker LLP was not a signatory to the engagement letter. Plaintiffs relied on apparent authority, equitable estoppel, and the firms’ shared membership in the verein, which they alleged held its offices out as “one Firm.” The Court granted both motions to dismiss and dismissed the complaint in its entirety. The Court observed that, for vicarious liability, courts have declined to treat vereins as a single entity based on a shared name, citing Dentons US LLP v. Republic of Guinea, 208 F. Supp. 3d 330, 344 (D.D.C. 2016). On the fiduciary duty claim, the Court explained:
Here plaintiffs have not brought an action against the verein itself, thus the link between ELEG and Baker LLP is even further attenuated than in Dentons. Further, plaintiffs have not alleged sufficient facts to establish principals [sic] of agency, as discussed above, nor have they alleged actions by Baker LLP which directly establishes a fiduciary relationship. Thus, the breach of fiduciary duty claim will be dismissed as against Baker LLP.
Slip op., pp. 6-7.
The Court rejected apparent authority because the alleged representations in the engagement letter were by ELEG, not Baker LLP, and the website statements “can only be attributed to non-party BMI.” Id., p. 2. It rejected equitable estoppel because the benefits plaintiffs alleged Baker LLP received, “further business opportunities and reputational benefits,” were “merely indirect.” Id., p. 4. The Court found no personal jurisdiction over ELEG under C.P.L.R. 302(a)(1) because ELEG performed all of its work in Peru, and sending the engagement letter, communications, and bills to plaintiffs in New York was not enough. Id., pp. 8-10.
Contact the Commercial Division Blog Committee at commercialdivisionblog@schlamstone.com if you or a client have questions concerning claims against law firms that operate through verein or affiliate structures, or personal jurisdiction over out-of-state professionals.