Commercial Division Blog

Court Allows Non-Signatory Principal to Compel Arbitration and Decides Arbitrability Where Arbitration Clauses Do Not Delegate It

Posted: November 18, 2026 / Written by: Thomas A. Kissane / Categories Agency, Arbitration, Motion to Compel

Court Allows Non-Signatory Principal to Compel Arbitration and Decides Arbitrability Where Arbitration Clauses Do Not Delegate It

On September 27, 2026, Justice Joel M. Cohen of the New York County Commercial Division held that an advertiser that did not sign a supply agreement could compel the counterparty to arbitrate, because the advertiser’s agent signed the agreement, and that the Court, not the arbitrator, decides arbitrability when the arbitration clauses do not clearly and unmistakably delegate that question. The case is Smaato, Inc. v. Zemanta, Inc., Index No. 651540/2026.

Smaato, Inc. (“Smaato”) and Zemanta, Inc. (“Zemanta”) agreed in a Supply Side Platform Agreement (the “SSPA”) to arbitrate disputes, and their dispute was proceeding before a JAMS arbitrator. System1 OpCo, LLC (“System1”), Zemanta’s advertising client, intervened and sought to compel Smaato to arbitrate with it in the same proceeding. Zemanta cross-moved for a temporary stay under C.P.L.R. 2201 pending a joinder ruling by the arbitrator. The Court granted System1’s petition and denied the stay. On the first ground, agency, the Court explained:

In these circumstances, because Zemanta executed the SSPA as System1’s contractually recognized agent, System1 may compel Smaato to arbitrate . . . . Smaato cannot seek to hold an advertiser client (System1) directly liable for payment defaults under an agreement while simultaneously evading its own contractually mandated arbitration provisions governing that same advertising inventory.

Slip op., pp. 3-4 (citations omitted). The Court relied on SSPA § 3.2, which described Zemanta as its clients’ “agent” and gave Smaato direct payment rights against the client for uncleared sums.

As an alternative ground, the Court held that System1 was an express third-party beneficiary of the SSPA’s indemnification provision, which extended to Zemanta’s “advertising clients.” Id., p. 4. On who decides arbitrability, the Court explained:

Zemanta’s argument that it agreed with Smaato to proceed under JAMS rules is immaterial because there is no evidence that Smaato and Zemanta agreed to delegate arbitrability determinations (presumptively a province of the Court) to the arbitrator.

Id., p. 5.

Contact the Commercial Division Blog Committee at commercialdivisionblog@schlamstone.com if you or a client have questions concerning compelling arbitration against or on behalf of non-signatories, or the delegation of arbitrability questions.