Commercial Division Blog

Posted: March 8, 2020 / Categories Commercial, Court Rules/Procedures

Late-Filed Motion to Amend Denied

On February 25, 2020, the First Department issued a decision in Ness Tech. SARL v. Pactera Tech. Intl. Ltd., 2020 NY Slip Op. 01310, affirming the dismissal of a late-filed motion to amend, explaining:

The motion court did not abuse its discretion in denying leave to amend. Defendant failed to explain why it waited until the brink of the discovery deadline to file its motion, and why it did not move by order to show cause or otherwise convey in a timely fashion the "emergency" that arose when it realized that plaintiffs' belated document production contained previously unknown admissions that formed the basis for the counterclaims. While defendant claims that it acted as soon as possible after its receipt of the 100,000-plus documents, the motion court reasonably concluded that the last-minute nature of the production could have been avoided by defendant, which did not move to compel more prompt production of the documents, which it admits it had sought since February 2018. Moreover, defendant's June 14, 2019 letter to the court primarily addressed plaintiff's failure to produce discovery substantiating its own damages claims, rather than the documents that it now claims support the proposed counterclaims.

Further, defendant's proposed new allegations — against plaintiff and two new defendants as well as other potentially relevant individuals implicated by the allegations — would inevitably entail substantial discovery and resulting delays. While CPLR 3025(b) motions may be granted at any time during the pendency of an action, defendant's explanation for the timing of its motion, combined with the scope of the proposed amendments, fails to show that the court, which anticipated not being able to try the case until 2021, was not reasonably concerned about the delay the new issues would generate.

(Internal quotations omitted).

In New York, the courts are very generous in allowing a party to amend its pleadings. However, there are limits to this generosity. Contact Schlam Stone & Dolan partner John Lundin at if you or a client have a question regarding whether it is too late to amend your claims or answer.